Mermaids Bakery's Pies & Treats

Our handcrafted pies are baked fresh with every order, they are made from scratch and we use local or organic fresh fruit when possible. Our crust is about the best there is, and our flavors are outstanding!

Mini Pies
Mini Pies
By special order only and 3 5-inch mini pies
PER FLAVOR 3/$21.95
Regular Pies
Large Pies
We make huge 9 inch pies by special order
(24 hours in advance please)
9” pies $21.95
Click here to call or place an order!
Pie Flavors

Sweet Tart Cherry

This one will melt your heart! It is sooo good, a local favorite

Key Lime

We hit the mark on this one…it has fans from Florida!

Grandma's Apple

Simple apple pie like Grandma would make

Pumpkin

A very special heirloom recipe, can add nuts too!

Chocolate Cream

Flavored with premium cocoa topped with real whipped cream and lightly dusted with cocoa powder.

Buckeye

Chocolate Cream layered with peanut butter cups and whipped cream on top.

Peach

When the peaches are in! We make peach pie! We a lucky to live in Colorado.

Pecan

cream based southern style pecan pie.

Lemon Silk

Light and delicate lemon flavor, topped with fresh whipped cream

Strawberry Rhubarb

A perfect combination!

Sweet Potato with Brown Sugar

need we say more? Order with or without pecans

Banana Cream

vanilla custard with fresh bananas topped with real whipped cream.

Coconut

Tons of coconut, topped with fresh whipped cream and toasted coconut.
Mermaid's Cookies
      All natural, made with real butter and premium ingredients. They are huge with their soft on the inside and crunchy on the outside perfection!

$1.75 each $18.00 a dozen (orders 1 flavor per dozen)

Chocolate Chip Cookies with or without nuts

I LOOOOVE Chocolate Chip Cookies, I had to come up with one like no other, this one is perfect.

Sea salt chocolate chip

Chocolate chip cookie baked with a light sprinkle of sea salt

Chocolate chip pretzel

Chocolate chip cookie baked with salted pretzel pieces

Salted Caramel

Cookie baked with Caramel and lightly sprinkled sea salt

Sugar

Buttery sugar cookie baked with sugar crystals on top

Snickerdoodle

Tons of cinnamon and crystal sugar, with buttery crumble... like no other!

Snickerdoodle Marshmellow

Our snickerdoodle studded with gooey marshmallows.

Peanut Butter

Peanut butter in the batter with peanut butter chips

Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip

Awesome!

Red Velvet

Tastes just like our cupcake! Studded with white chocolate chips!
Yummy Sweet Treats
      All our treats are perfect for meetings, special events, breakfast events, dessert bars. We can make mini versions of all our treats for bite size presentations.
      Guests love mini desserts!

Super Star Brownies - with or without nuts

Sea Salt Brownies - Topped with mini chocolate chips and sea salt

(can be cut into 12 large or 24 small brownies)

$3.50 each $36.00 a tray

Coconut Macaroons

chewy on the inside, crunchy on the outside, local favorite

Plain $1.75 each
Chocolate Dipped $2.25 each
Chocolate and Pecan dipped $2.50 each

Click here to call or place an order!